| Platinum | Godfather's Pizza |
| Gold | Smoked American BBQ |
| Silver | Roadhouse Diner |
| Bronze | Clark & Lewie's |
| Top Pick | Beef & Bone |
| Top Pick | Bourbon Chicken |
| Top Pick | Five On Black |
| Top Pick | Magpie |
| Top Pick | The Montana Club |
| Top Pick | Tracy's Family Restaurant |
| Black Bear Diner |